Last Updated on: April 21, 2023 by Crystal Uys
Proper nutrition is just as essential for your cat as for you. Like humans, a poor diet for your cat can lead to obesity, diseases, malnutrition, and even premature death. The problem is that many cat owners don’t have the time to study feline nutrition, so they pick the first food they find in the grocery store and hope it will give their pet the nutrients it needs to thrive. Choosing the perfect diet for your cat requires more effort, so we’ve put together this article to help remove some of the guesswork of proper feline nutrition.
Please keep reading to find our reviews of the 12 best cat foods, including the best wet and freeze-dried raw options on the market today.
A Quick Comparison of Our Favorites in 2023
|Best Overall||Smalls Human-Grade Fresh Cat Food Subscription||
||Click to Save 40% Use code: ConsciousCat2023|
|Best Wet Cat Food||Hound & Gatos 98% Lamb, Chicken & Salmon Cat Food||
|Best Freeze-Dried Raw Cat Food||Vital Essentials Rabbit Dinner Patties||
|Darwin's Natural Fresh Chicken Cat Food||
|The Honest Kitchen Dehydrated Grain-Free Chicken Cat Food||
The 12 Best Cat Foods:
1. Smalls Human-Grade Fresh Cat Food Subscription – Best Overall
Click to Save 40% on Smalls & Use Code ConsciousCat2023
|Main ingredients:||Chicken, Chicken Liver, Green Beans, Peas, Water (Sufficient for Processing)|
|Calories:||200 kcal/5 oz|
Smalls is a cat food delivery service that provides protein-rich formulas in textures cats love. The company’s Fresh Smooth Bird recipe is our pick for best overall cat food thanks to its familiar, pate-like texture and protein-focused recipe. With real chicken as its first two ingredients and a unique blend of vitamins and minerals, you know you’re providing your kitty with the best fresh recipe possible. In addition, this recipe has a low carbohydrate content and is high in moisture to ensure cats get the hydration they need to thrive.
Since Smalls is a delivery service, it is pricier than most foods in the grocery store. You’ll also rely on their deliveries to get your cat’s food since it’s unavailable in stores. That said, their convenient subscription service is easy to configure to a delivery schedule that works with your budget and needs.
- High in protein
- Real chicken as the first two ingredients
- Convenient delivery service
- Low in carbohydrates
- Rich in moisture
- Pricier than most other cat food options
- Not available in store
2. Hound & Gatos Lamb, Chicken & Salmon – Best Wet Cat Food
|Main ingredients:||Lamb, Chicken, Lamb Broth, Salmon, Agar-Agar|
|Calories:||199 kcal/5.5 oz can|
The Hound & Gatos 98% Lamb, Chicken & Salmon Grain-Free Canned Cat Food is a plant protein-free wet food perfect for your cat’s carnivorous diet. This recipe is made of high-quality lamb, chicken, and salmon, with the majority (98%) of the recipe’s protein being derived from animal sources. This limited key ingredient formula has no added carbohydrates. This food has a pate-like texture that most cats are drawn to right away, though some may find it too thick. This can be remedied by adding a smidge of water to thin the consistency.
This recipe has a strong scent and contains a lot of gel on top. This can make this recipe a no-go for some pickier cats.
- Free of plant proteins
- Low in carbohydrates
- 98% animal protein
- Pate-like texture
- Strong scent
- Somewhat gelatinous texture
3. Vital Essentials Rabbit Dinner Patties – Best Freeze-Dried Raw Cat Food
|Main ingredients:||Rabbit, Rabbit Liver, Rabbit Heart, Rabbit Kidney, Rabbit Lung|
Vital Essentials Rabbit Dinner Patties Grain-Free Limited Ingredient Freeze-Dried Cat Food is our pick for the best overall dehydrated and freeze-dried raw cat food. These patties provide a limited-ingredient cat food, perfect for pet owners looking to reduce their pet’s exposure to overly processed food. It’s made with a novel protein—rabbit—and features organ meat such as liver, heart, and kidney. This formula is free of any additional flavorings, fillers, and artificial ingredients. The raw meat recipe is freeze-dried during manufacturing to preserve the nutrients and maintain freshness.
This formula contains bones in its patties, so that’s something to keep in mind as you feed it to your cat. Some bones are reportedly large, which could cause issues if you’re not careful. Also, as with most freeze-dried food, it must be rehydrated before serving, which can be time-consuming.
- Novel protein
- Limited ingredient diet
- Contains organ meat
- No artificial flavors or fillers
- Freeze-dried to maintain nutrients
- Some patties may contain large bones
- Time-consuming to rehydrate
4. Darwin’s Natural Fresh Cat Food Chicken Recipe
Click to Get 10 Pounds of Darwin’s For Just $14.95!
|Main ingredients:||Chicken Meat, Chicken Necks with Bone, Chicken Gizzards, Chicken Livers, Chicken Hearts|
Like Smalls, Darwin’s Natural Pet Products produces fresh and natural food for cats. Their chicken recipe provides a great source of protein and B vitamins like B1, which cats need for proper carbohydrate metabolism. The meat is hormone and chemical-free, so it’s something you can feel good about feeding your cat. This raw formula is made primarily of muscle meat, organs, and bones and is minimally processed to preserve nutrients.
Also, like Smalls, Darwin’s is a pet food delivery service, so you should expect to pay more than you would for food in your local pet store. There are also some consumer complaints about the food not arriving frozen as it should be.
- Made with real muscle meat and organs
- Hormone and chemical free
- Minimally processed
- Convenient delivery service
- A bit on the expensive side
- Some consumers had issues with shipping
5. The Honest Kitchen Dehydrated Grain-Free Chicken Cat Food
|Main ingredients:||Chicken, Sweet Potatoes, Potatoes, Flaxseed, Whole Eggs|
|Calories:||128 kcal/ 1 oz packet|
The Honest Kitchen Dehydrated Grain-Free Chicken Cat Food is a USA-made food packed with whole food ingredients such as free-range chicken and sweet potatoes. Add warm water to serve this meal that will rehydrate to four times its weight. This formula features no preservatives, fillers, or GMO ingredients. It is boosted with probiotics to help support your cat’s digestion and features bone broth for extra flavor and protein. This formula is great for kittens and adults but won’t meet the nutritional needs of active or senior cats.
This recipe is higher in carbs than others that made our list. It also has an average amount of protein and more fat than others.
- Expands to four times its weight
- No preservatives or GMO ingredients
- Boosted with probiotics for digestion
- Made with free-range chicken
- High in carbs
- Lower in protein than other similar products
6. Dr. Elsey’s cleanprotein Turkey Formula Grain-Free Canned Cat Food
|Main ingredients:||Turkey, Turkey Broth, Turkey Liver, Dried Egg Product, Natural Flavor|
|Calories:||202 kcal/5.5 oz can|
Dr. Elsey’s cleanprotein Turkey Formula Grain-Free Canned Cat Food is a low glycemic formula that provides just 4% of energy from carbs. It features real turkey as the first ingredient and turkey liver as the third, providing a hefty dose of species-appropriate protein. This formula is supplemented with vitamins and minerals like riboflavin and biotin. It contains no added fillers or preservatives and has a smooth pate texture cats love.
Cats that are particular about the consistency of their food may not like the gelatin layer on top of the pate.
- Low in carbohydrates
- Real turkey as the first ingredient
- Contains organ meat for protein
- Supplemented with vitamins and minerals
- No added fillers
- Gelatinous layer may be a turn-off for some cats
7. Nature’s Logic Feline Rabbit Feast Grain-Free Canned Cat Food
|Main ingredients:||Rabbit, Water Sufficient for Processing, Pork Liver, Dried Egg Product, Montmorillonite Clay|
|Calories:||212 kcal/5.5 oz can|
Nature’s Logic Feline Rabbit Feast Grain-Free Canned Cat Food is a grain and gluten-free formula low in carbohydrates. It has real rabbit as its first ingredient and boasts over 90% animal protein to help mimic your cat’s natural diet. Rabbit is a novel protein which can be great for cats with allergies to other protein sources. That said, it does contain pork liver, which doesn’t make it a single-source protein. This recipe includes whole foods like apples which can be good for cats thanks to its calcium and vitamin-rich skin, and blueberries for a dose of antioxidants and fiber. In addition, this formula contains naturally occurring taurine, an essential amino acid cats need in large amounts for eye health.
This food is extremely expensive, making it inaccessible for many cat owners.
- Rabbit is a novel protein
- Over 90% animal protein
- Contains whole foods like fruits and vegetables
- Contains naturally occurring taurine
- Not a single source protein
- Very high price
8. Ziwi Peak Venison Recipe Canned Cat Food
|Main ingredients:||Venison, Venison Tripe, Venison Liver, Chickpeas, Venison Lung, Venison Heart|
|Calories:||222 kcal/6.5 oz can|
The Ziwi Peak Venison Recipe Canned Cat Food is a venison-based recipe containing muscle meat, broth, and organs like the liver, lungs, and heart. As with most Ziwi Peak recipes, this formula includes the company’s standard green-lipped mussels, providing a species-appropriate source of glucosamine and chondroitin for joint health. This single-protein recipe is made without cheap fillers. All the meat that Ziwi Peak uses for its recipes are ethically and sustainably sourced.
The company uses tin with an internal lacquer for their cans. These cans are “BPA-NI”, which translates to “BPA non-intent,” meaning no BPA is intentionally added to the lacquer but it cannot be labeled BPA-free.
This recipe contains chickpeas which increase its carbohydrate, making this recipe moderate in carbs.
- Single protein recipe
- Sustainably sourced venison
- Can promote joint health
- Contains muscle and organ meat
- No artificial ingredients or fillers
- Cans may contain BPA
- Higher in carbohydrates
9. Tiki Cat Succulent Chicken in Chicken Consommé Canned Cat Food
|Main ingredients:||Chicken, Chicken Broth, Sunflower Seed Oil, Calcium Lactate, Dicalcium Phosphate|
|Calories:||63 kcal/2.8 oz can|
The Tiki Cat Puka Puka Luau Succulent Chicken in Chicken Consomme Grain-Free Canned Cat Food is made with real chicken and slathered in a hydrating chicken broth to boost your cat’s hydration levels. It is made without any artificial coloring or flavors. Its shredded texture is not unlike canned chicken, but it can be hit or miss with cats.
This formula features sunflower seed oil as its third most prominent ingredient. This oil is often added to canned food as a fat source but isn’t as diverse as other carnivore-appropriate fatty acids such as fish oil.
This recipe has zero carbohydrates which may not be as healthy as it sounds. Cats need energy that they acquire from protein, fats, and carbohydrates. Carbs may help promote proper metabolic feeding balance.
- Made with real chicken
- Very hydrating
- No artificial colors
- Rich in animal-sourced protein
- No carbohydrates at all
- Heavy emphasis on plant-sourced fat
10. Weruva Press Your Dinner! Chicken Paté
|Main ingredients:||Chicken, Chicken Broth, Natural Flavor, Sunflower Oil, Xanthan Gum|
|Calories:||93 kcal/ 3 oz can|
The Weruva Classic Cat Paté, Press Your Dinner with Chicken Wet Cat Food is made with wholesome ingredients and is gently pureed into a texture that cats will either love or hate. The texture is a bit pudding-like in consistency, making it a great pick for senior cats or those with dental issues. It’s made with real chicken and chicken broth for a high protein, hydrating meal. It has an 82% moisture content to promote urinary tract health and ensure your kitty gets the hydration it needs to thrive. In addition, this formula is free of artificial colors, flavors, and MSG.
There appears to be some issues with consistency from can-to-can. Some have slightly different scents or colorations that may turn cats off.
- High in moisture
- Made with real chicken
- Free of artificial colors
- Jelly-like consistency is great for seniors
- Texture can be a turn off to some cats
- Inconsistent from can to can
11. Stella & Chewy’s Tummy Ticklin’ Turkey Dinner Morsels Freeze-Dried Raw Cat Food
|Main ingredients:||Turkey With Ground Bone, Turkey Liver, Turkey Gizzard, Pumpkin Seed, Potassium Chloride|
Stella & Chewy’s Tummy Ticklin’ Turkey Dinner Morsels Freeze-Dried Raw Cat Food combines the benefits of a raw diet and the convenience of freeze-dried meals. You can serve these morsels as-is or rehydrate them by adding water. Rehydrating the morsels is a great option if you know your kitty isn’t getting the hydration it needs from its water bowl. This formula is made in a USA-based kitchen with responsibly sourced, cage-free turkey and organic fruits and vegetables. The recipe is 98% turkey, organs, and bone. It doesn’t have any artificial preservatives or colors added.
Rehydrating the morsels can take a while, and they sometimes don’t mix well with the water. There are also reports of the food being crumbly upon arrival.
- Can serve dry or rehydrated
- Made in USA-based kitchen
- Made with cage-free turkey
- 98% animal protein
- No artificial preservatives
- Inconsistency in morsel texture
- Can take a while to rehydrate
12. Primal Chicken & Salmon Formula Raw Freeze-Dried Nuggets
|Main ingredients:||Chicken With Ground Bone, Chicken Livers, Salmon, Organic Pumpkin Seeds, Organic Sunflower Seeds|
Primal Chicken & Salmon Formula Nuggets Grain-Free Raw Freeze-Dried Cat Food is made with antibiotic and hormone-free chicken meat and organs. Chicken accounts for the bulk of the protein in this recipe, but it also contains wild-caught salmon as one of its main ingredients to provide your pet with a good source of omega-fatty acids. This formula focuses on whole-food nutrition and has no synthetic vitamins or minerals in its ingredient list. It’s fast and easy to serve when rehydrated with water or Primal Raw Goat Milk. In addition, this formula doesn’t have excessive bone content and is free of artificial ingredients.
This recipe heavily focuses on fruits and vegetables, which aren’t necessarily species-appropriate for your little carnivore.
- Antibiotic and hormone-free chicken
- Salmon for omega fatty acids
- No synthetic vitamins or minerals
- Easy to serve
- Some cats may be allergic to salmon
- Heavy focus on fruit and vegetable ingredients
Buyer’s Guide: How to Choose the Best Cat Foods
Are you still feeling overwhelmed at all your cat food options? Raw, wet, dehydrated – how can you know which food type will be best for your cat’s needs? Read on to learn more about choosing the best cat food for your feline family members.
Raw Food Diets
A raw food diet for cats is a highly controversial topic. Your kitty’s wild ancestors certainly ate raw foods to survive, but that doesn’t necessarily mean your highly pampered domesticated kitty has the same nutritional needs.
A raw diet focuses on unprocessed foods made with natural ingredients. You already know that your obligate carnivore needs animal tissues to thrive, and raw foods provide this by placing a heavy emphasis on uncooked meat and organs. Many raw diets also include ground bone for calcium and phosphorus.
Raw diets generally provide high-quality nutrition with fewer processed ingredients. As a result, they may promote better digestion.
It’s important to know that seeing the term “raw” on your cat’s food bag doesn’t automatically make it healthy.
The biggest concern with a raw diet is that it may pose an infectious disease risk for both your cat and you. A one-year study tested commercially available raw foods for bacteria and found that nearly 25% of the samples tested positive for bacteria like Salmonella spp. and Listeria monocytogenes.
Raw diets may put your cat at risk of nutritional imbalances and pose foreign body risks (e.g., bones).
Wet Food Diets
A wet (or canned) food diet is one of the most often recommended cat diets.
Canned food is designed to help increase your cat’s water intake. Most wet food has a moisture content of around 75% (compared to dry foods’ 6% to 10%). Dehydration is a huge issue for indoor cats, leading to health problems like urinary tract blockages and constipation.
Wet food is highly palatable and strongly scented, two factors that can entice a picky or sick cat into eating.
The biggest downside of a wet food diet is that it is expensive, especially when compared to dry food. However, raw and dehydrated food diets are likely much the same in price.
Dehydrated & Freeze-Dried Food Diets
Freeze drying is a process whereby food is frozen and put into a vacuum to sublimate the water content. The resulting product is then put into an air-tight package to remove any remaining moisture, providing a much more shelf-stable food. Freeze-dried cat food isn’t cooked or pasteurized, making it raw.
Dehydrating is a different technique cat food manufacturers use to achieve the same goal as freeze drying—removing the moisture to create food with a stable shelf life. The dehydration process requires heat, but not enough for the resulting food to be considered cooked.
Both processes (freeze drying and dehydration) are popular options as the quality nutrients and vitamins of the food’s ingredients are not lost through cooking.
The problem with feeding your cat dehydrated or freeze-dried diets is the same as if you were feeding a raw diet. The biggest concern is contamination, as illness-causing pathogens can survive the freeze-drying and dehydration processes.
There may be risks of nutritional deficiencies due to dietary imbalances, though this can be sidestepped by choosing a food labeled as complete and balanced. Many dehydrated and freeze-dried cat foods are designed to be used as meal toppers and not your cat’s sole food source, so they don’t contain all the vitamins and minerals your kitty needs to thrive.
What About Dry Food?
You’ve probably noticed by now that the list above contained no mention of dry food at all. You’re probably wondering why that is, and the answer comes down to the following:
- It is low in moisture.
- It is high in carbohydrates.
- It focuses on protein sourced from plants versus animals.
- It can promote overeating.
1. It is low in moisture.
The biggest difference between wet, raw, and dehydrated cat food and dry food is the moisture levels. Dry food contains around 10% water; the remaining 90% is dry matter like carbohydrates, fats, and vitamins. Wet food, on the other hand, contains approximately 70% water. This is especially important if your cat has certain health conditions that would do well with a moisture-rich diet.
2. It is high in carbohydrates.
Carbohydrates act as an essential energy source for many animals. However, this isn’t as true for cats as they’ve evolved to derive most of their energy from the protein and fat they ingest. Therefore, carbohydrates should play a small part in a cat’s diet. Unfortunately, dry food is much higher in carbs than other food types.
According to PetMD, diets that are too high in carbs can cause weight gain and related health issues like diabetes.
3. It focuses on protein sourced from plants versus animals.
Many dry foods require grains like rice to assist with kibble processing. In addition, some foods contain more plant-based proteins than meat, which is not ideal for your obligate carnivore kitty who needs animal protein to thrive.
4. It can promote overeating.
Cats evolved to eat diets rich in protein and fats but deficient in carbohydrates. As such, consuming fat and protein does a better job of signaling to a cat that it is satiated and should stop eating. Unfortunately, consuming carbohydrates does not have the same effect, resulting in overeating and, eventually, obesity.
For the overall best cat food, Smalls’ Human-Grade Fresh Cat Food provides cats with a low carbohydrate and high protein, species-appropriate food in a texture they’ll love. The best wet cat food, Hound & Gatos 98% Lamb, Chicken & Salmon Grain-Free Canned Cat Food, is a plant protein-free recipe with 98% animal protein for a formula designed to keep your obligate carnivore happy and healthy. Finally, the best dehydrated and freeze-dried raw cat food, Vital Essentials Rabbit Dinner Patties, provides cats with a novel protein source containing the organ meats they would eat in the wild.
We hope our reviews have shed some light on the always-important topic of feline nutrition. Now that you know the best cat foods on the market, you can decide which will be healthiest and most appropriate for your kitty and its tastes.
Featured Image Credit: Pixel-Shot, Shutterstock
About the author
Cat mom to Ivy – a feisty little rescue kitten that is her one and only child. For now! Throughout her life, she has been introduced to the special love that can be found in the bond with a cat. Having owned multiple felines, she is more than certain that their love is unmatched, unconditional and unlike any other. With a passion to educate the public about everything, there is to know about felines, their behavior, and their unique personalities, Crystal is devoted to making sure that all cats and their owners know the importance of conscious living – and loving!