When Cats Refuse to Take Pills

This post contains affiliate links*

When it comes to giving pills to pets, dog parents tend to have it easier. Put the pill in a little bit of peanut butter or cheese, and most dogs will think they’re getting a treat and wont’ even notice the pill. When it comes to cats, it’s usually not quite that simple. Rumor has it there are some cats who will allow their owners to pill them easily, but if my personal experience and that with veterinary clients is any indication, they’re few and far between.

Options for pilling cats

There are several options for pilling a cat, from quickly shoving the pill deep into the cat’s mouth to using a pill gun to pill pockets to Pill Masker to crushing up the pill and mixing it with a small amount of food (caution: the latter may not be appropriate for all types of medication, check with your veterinarian to be sure.)

Many medications are also available in liquid form, which may make dosing easier for some cat owners. Some can even be compounded into tuna or chicken flavored liquids. Another option may be transdermal delivery: the medication is compounded into a cream that is rubbed on the inside of the cat’s ear.

And of course, there’s always the ever popular kitty burrito method (although I’m sure cats would disagree with its popularity).

In theory, all of these sound great. But there are some cats who simply won’t cooperate. And unless you’ve had one of these cats, you may not understand the emotional toll this can take on the owner.

There are some cats who simply won’t cooperate. And unless you’ve had one of these cats, you may not understand the emotional toll this can take on the owner.

Cats who refuse to take pills, and the humans who love them

I recently talked to a friend whose 16-year-old cat was diagnosed with hyperthyroidism, and needs to take medication twice a day to regulate thyroid function. She can’t pill the cat, he won’t take pill pockets, and he refuses to take the liquid form of the medication in his food. She tried the transdermal version, to no avail. She kept trying, for several weeks. At this point, the cat runs from her whenever he sees her coming. He no longer sleeps on the bed with her, or sits next to her when she reads or watches TV. The bond between the two of them is completely broken. My friend is stressed and upset, and so is her cat.

The bond between cat and human is completely broken.

The cat is not a candidate for radioactive iodine treatment, nor is he a good candidate for surgery. The medication is the only viable option to control his disease. My friend is at the end of her rope: she feels like she’s killing her cat because she can’t medicate him, and most of the time she feels like she doesn’t even have a cat anymore since he wants nothing to do with her.

Sometimes, deciding not to medicate is the right answer

I told my friend that she has another choice. Making a treatment decision can also mean choosing not to treat. She can choose to stop giving her cat the medication, and restore the relationship with her cat. She will need to understand what will happen physiologically to a hyperthyroid cat with no treatment. She will need to accept that this will most likely shorten her cat’s life. She will need to monitor her cat closely for even subtle changes, and she will probably eventually need to be ready to make the euthanasia decision.

She’s afraid to tell her vet that she wants to stop treatment. Understandably, this may not be a popular decision with some vets. Vets are trained to heal and cure. But most vets also understand that they’re not just treating their patient, they’re treating the bond between patient and human. And when treatment interferes with the bond to the extent it did for my friend, shouldn’t they discuss this alternative with their clients?

Most vets understand that they’re not just treating their patient, they’re treating the bond between patient and human.

Deciding to stop treatment: my personal experience

I had to make this choice with Buckley. I was fortunate that I had my vet’s complete support when I decided to stop treating her restrictive cardiomyopathy. She was on multiple cardiac medications, and for several months, she happily took them with pill pockets. Once she started to refuse the pill pockets, the only way I could have gotten the meds into her was through force. Buckley was the kind of cat who, at a mere seven pounds, needed multiple veterinary assistants to restrain her to get anything done. I don’t think she ever had an exam that didn’t require at least mild sedation. There was no way I could have pilled her, nor would I have wanted to put a cat with heart disease through the twice daily stress of it. I also knew that she would come to dread contact with me, and I knew I couldn’t have handled that.

I made the choice to stop her heart medications, knowing full well that it would shorten her already much too short life even further. But I also knew it was the right decision for her, and for me. She lived for another month after I stopped her meds, and except for the last few days of her life, her quality of life was good.  If anything, our bond became deeper, knowing that our time together was limited.

If my friend chooses to stop treatment for her cat, she will most likely shorten her cat’s life, too. But what she will gain, in my opinion, far outweighs what she will loose. She will get the loving relationship with her cat back.

This post was first published in April 2011, and has been updated.

*The Conscious Cat is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites. This means that if you decide to purchase through any of our links, we get a small commission. We only spread the word about products and services we’ve either used or would use ourselves.

119 Comments on When Cats Refuse to Take Pills

  1. Nancy Cowan
    August 3, 2019 at 10:04 pm (4 months ago)

    My cat Maggie, who is turning 16 this month, is hyperthyroid. I was feeding her Y/D for a few years and it worked well but was difficult as I have other cats. She is now getting Felimazole, a little pink pill, twice a day with a piller. Fortunately she is easy to pill and I know this isn’t always the case. If a piller doesn’t work, try Y/D. I bought that from my vet and it’s made by Science Diet.

    Reply
  2. Betty
    August 2, 2019 at 9:34 am (4 months ago)

    I am currently dealing with this problem with my senior gal and hyperthyroidism – 2 pills a day . Pill pockets worked for awhile then pill paste, there is no way I can give her a pill. She won’t eat anything because I’ve been hiding the pill in it. Some days there will be 3-4 cans of food open until she decides to eat something. I’m at the point of if she eats it great, if she won’t she won’t. The stress to her and me doesn’t make it worth it for this 14 yr old kitty. I certainly understand your option to not medicate, I’ve been thinking this way for a while.

    Reply
    • Nancy Cowan
      August 3, 2019 at 10:28 pm (4 months ago)

      Betty – I just want to add to my comment about feeding Y/D. First of all it is made by Hill’s. And also, if you decide you are interested in trying this, of course talk to your vet. I know it works in a different way then Felimazole but I can’t remember the details without researching it again so you may want to do that first. It is just another option if you can’t pill and it definitely worked for Maggie for at least 3 years until I found out about Felimazole.

      Reply
  3. Caz
    June 28, 2019 at 7:15 pm (5 months ago)

    When my cat was Ill. And he didn’t want tabs. I put the pill in a sticky. The long cat sticks they pliable you can hide the pill and hold it so it is completely covered worked brilliantly for my cat. Who was v clued up.

    Reply
  4. Nat
    June 28, 2019 at 4:08 am (5 months ago)

    I’ve been struggling with my cat to give her medication 3x daily. I am so stressed out and so is my cat. She’s hiding from me and when I do ‘catch’ her she bites and scratches me. The vet says she needs the meds to fight a bacterial infection. I do believe her but I cannot do it like this for a month. I’ve decided to offer it to her with her food. If she eats it, great. If not… I need to let it go.

    So far she might have ingested her meds, or not, but she’s already happier…. going outside, enjoying the sunshine, hunting for mice. I don’t know how much longer she’ll have but it’s no longer up to me. I’ve done my best and I will take her to the vet if she’s running a fever again or becomes lethargic but I’m not going to fight with her and shove a pill down her throat which she will puke out half an hour later.

    Thank you for this article. I needed this.

    Reply
    • Ann Heatherton
      July 31, 2019 at 10:41 pm (4 months ago)

      Your vet could have given your cat a convenia injection which is a slow-release long-lasting antibiotic to fight infections. Then you would not have to go through this house’ll. Please ask for one of those next time.

      Reply

Leave a comment

First time visitors: please read our Comment Guidelines.